Showing posts with label Real estate project review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Real estate project review. Show all posts

Sunday, 24 June 2018

Realty cases against Aliens, Lodha, Mantri, others pile up at Telangana state commission.

It's raining complaints from home buyers at the Telangana State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission. At least so it seems from the official records, which suggest that close to 200 such cases have been filed with the commission in the last one year alone between June 2014 and June 2015.

Prominent builders that find themselves on this list of'accused', include Aliens Group, Lodha Group, Aditya Constructions, Mantri Developers, Lanco Hills, Janapriya, Royal Home Constructions, among many others. Given the ongoing turmoil on the premises of the Tellapur-based Aliens Space Station-I venture, it comes as no surprise that the maximum complaints, i.e. 115, lodged so far are against it.

Cheated Buyers


"Most of these complaints are with regard to an inordinate delay in completing the projects," confirmed an official from the state's consumer affairs, food and civil supplies department, of which the commission is a part. He also added that the numbers are fast increasing with every passing day.

Unfortunately, however, there seems to be no immediate respite in sight for these customers who have been running from pillar to post to recover either their properties or lump sum deposits. This, as the Telangana state commission  even after a lapse of eight months since its separation from the Andhra Pradesh wing is yet to get a president to head its day-to-day affairs. Result, piling of files with no one to attend to.

"It is frustrating to say the least. With the developer not paying heed to our concerns and the government too not intervening in the matter, we have no place to go to for help," said Prashanth V, an aggrieved customer of Aliens Group, while ruing the critical situation facing scores of home buyers who have been left with no choice but to pay hefty EMIs as banks too have refused to cooperate. The tragedy: zero guarantee of a home at the end of the road.

Incidentally, the Telangana government has failed to appoint a president, despite orders from the Hyderabad High Court.

"Our sources tell us that the realty mafia is hand-in-glove with the government in delaying the appointment," said another home buyer on condition of anonymity, adding,"They are waiting for the sector to revive before their cases can come up for hearing before the commission."

While the commissioner of consumer affairs, food & civil supplies, Rajat Kumar, refused to react to these allegations, he did admit to an unprecedented delay in the appointment of the president."There is no denying that. But there are three district consumer forums in the city, so it isn't like there is a major delay in hearing of cases. We are hopeful that the appointment issue will be resolved in the next one month," he said.

Times view: The government should immediately appoint a new president at the earliest considering that the redressal forum is imperative to resolve the grievances of the common man. Apart from Real Estate-related matters there are several other cases, which need speedy disposal.

Join the Largest Community of Whatsapp Group of Real Estate Buyers in India on Best Real Estate Review Website for more information and news related to builders.

Friday, 22 June 2018

Hooda’s land largesse for pvt builder ‘clear fraud’, SC restores it to HUDA

A landmark Supreme Court judgement has given huge relief to farmers/landowners, while quashing the “illegal” and “deceptive” licensing of 280 acres of land in Rohtak, Haryana in 2006 to Uddar Gaggan Properties Ltd.

This serves as a body blow to former Haryana Chief Minister Bhupinder Singh Hooda and other state officials who are facing multiple probes for facilitating the private enrichment of builders through similar illegal licensing.

Cheated Buyers


“The unholy nexus to promote the private interests” of builders by “transfer of resources of poor for the benefit of the rich”, through “gross abuse of law” and “clear fraud” referred to in the judgement, has been detailed in a series of media exposes, beginning October 8, 2012, first about the irregularities in property dealings involving real estate major DLF and Congress President Sonia Gandhi’s son-in-law Robert Vadra, while later going on to uncover Hooda’s modus operandi to favor a host of other builders, including Uddar Gaggan.

Hooda’s modus operandi

This earlier expose had revealed that Hooda was acquiring land from poor, illiterate farmers at a low rate in the name of ‘public interest’ only to later license this to builders after bestowing out-of-turn favors that helped the land value increase exponentially.

The facts disclosed therein, had pointed to Hooda’s motivation in licensing a staggering 24,825 acres of land during his 10-year tenure as Chief Minister, as against just 8,550.32 acres by successive Chief Ministers in the 23 years preceding Mr. Hooda’s rise to power in 2004.

Join the Largest Community of Whatsapp Group of Real Estate Buyers in India on Best Real Estate Review Website for more information and news related to builders.

Thursday, 21 June 2018

No relief for Lodha group on sale of flats in Hyderabad's Bellezza project.


The bench questioned the builder and the authorities as to how builders were being per mitted to go ahead despite failing to provide basic facilities like parking.




The Hyderabad HC on Friday made it clear that it would call for a report from the GHMC on the ongoing tussle between Mumbai-based developer Lodha Constructions and the apartment owners of Lodha Bellezza at Kukatpally .

The bench of acting Chief Justice Ramesh Ranganathan and Justice M Ganga Rao, hearing a plea filed by Lodha Constructions, also refused to vacate a single judge's order restraining the builder from selling flats in Lodha Bellezza and Lodha Meridien and posted the matter to next week.

Earlier, following a plea by Bellezza Apartment Owners Association, a single judge stayed the proposed demolition of acompound wall built between Bellezza and Meridian and di rected the authorities to ensure that no sales are registered in respect of vacant flats. Aggrieved by this, the developer filed a plea urging the court to vacate the stay on sale of flats. But flat owners in the two schemes, particularly Lodha Bellezza, are accusing the builder of misleading them and GHMC.

The bench questioned the builder and the authorities as to how builders were being per mitted to go ahead despite failing to provide basic facilities like parking. Stating that there is no urgency to intervene, the bench declined to vacate the restraint order passed. “At a time we are struggling to reach out to those who are weak and cannot afford to wait for long, we cannot spare time, that too on an urgent basis, for those who can afford to wait,“ the bench said.

Join the Largest Community of Whatsapp Group of Real Estate Buyers in India on Best Real Estate Review Website for more information and news related to builders.

Friday, 15 June 2018

Shop owners accuse Navi Mumbai mall developers of fraud by Akshar developers.

The shop owners at City Centre Mall in Navi Mumbai have filed a criminal case against the developer of the mall in the Vashi First Class Court, accusing them of fraud.

Speaking on behalf of the shop owners, their lawyer, Nelson Rajan, said,"At present, the judicial magistrate has deferred the hearing till December 15. However, the 

magistrate has warned all the 15 individuals of the defending party to be present in the court on December 15, or else the order will be passed on the same day."

Cheated Buyers

The allegation 
The shop owners have accused the developers Wellwisher Constructions & Finance Pvt Ltd and Akshar Developers of deceiving them. The shop owners have alleged that the developers had made them sign an'agreement for lease' instead of the 'agreement for sale', despite receiving the full payment in 2007 from each shop owner.
The owners said that the reason why they didn't object to this move initially was because the developers had assured them that it would neither affect them nor their business. 



However, now that the mall has reportedly changed hands, the developers have asked the shop owners to vacate the shops, forcing them to move court.

Sensing that a single shop owner would not stand a chance fighting the powerful developers, the shop owners united under the banner of City Centre Mall Shop Owners 

Association (CCMOA). According to R K Sharma, chairperson of the association, "It is written in the allotment letter that we have bought the shops in the mall. 

However, at the time of signing an agreement, the developers forced us to sign 'agreement for lease', saying that the land for the mall had been taken on lease from 

CIDCO. As we had faith in them and were ignorant about the rules and regulations, we bought their theory and signed the agreement. None of us had ever thought that 

something like this would come up in future." 

The shop owners said that they didn't doubt the developers' integrity, until the management started ignoring basic maintenance and repair work of the mall. "In early 

2010, when we noticed the management's lack of interest in executing restoration work, we questioned them for their negligence. They dodged us by saying that the mall 

has been transferred to Bombay Infrastructure Private Limited. A few days later, we received letters from the original developers and the new one, asking us to vacate 

the shops, as they were given to us on lease," said a shop owner, requesting anonymity.

Expertspeak
Commenting on the issue, city-based real estate experts are baffled over the developer's decision of forcing the shop owners to sign an agreement for lease, when the 

allotment letters talk about sale of the shops.

The other side
When contacted, Abhijeet Bhansali of Wellwisher Constructions & Finance Pvt Ltd said, "I do not have information on the issue, so I cannot comment on it. Our lawyer is following the case in the court."

Join the Largest Community of Whatsapp Group of Real Estate Buyers in India on Best Real Estate Review Website for more information and news related to builders.

Wednesday, 6 June 2018

Trump brand debuts in Delhi-NCR market, hopes to generate over USD 1bn from all properties in India

Global real estate brand Trump Towers that made a debut in the Delhi-NCR market on Wednesday, with a fourth property after Mumbai, Pune, and Kolkata, hopes to generate roughly over a billion dollars in terms of sales potential from all its properties in India.

“We hope to generate roughly well over a billion dollars in terms of sales potential of all the Trump properties in India,” Kalpesh Mehta, partner of Tribeca, India representative of Trump Organisation told Moneycontrol.

US President Donald Trump’s eldest son, Donald Trump Jr, is expected to be in India in the first quarter of 2018 “to celebrate the success of both the Delhi-NCR project and the Kolkata project.” “Plans are underway and I am hopeful that he will be here in the first quarter of 2018,” Mehta said. “The total project cost of the luxury residential project to come up in Gurgaon is Rs 1,200 crore,” he said. M3M and Tribeca will develop 250 ultra-luxury residences under a brand license from The Trump Organisation. The project is also expected to have a 35,000 sq ft area of amenities.

Real Estate Project Review - Cheated Buyers


Trump Towers Delhi-NCR will be characterised by iconic twin towers rising over 600 feet that will be amongst the tallest towers in the region. “True to Trump form this will be an all-glass building rising 600 ft in the area and seen from everywhere,” Mehta said.

On offer are three sizes – 3500 sq ft apartments, 4500 sq ft apartments and 6000 sq ft apartments. In the first phase of sale, the apartments which will have three and four bedroom options will be sold in a price range of Rs 5 crore to Rs 10 crore. "This will be the biggest Trump project in India with a development of over one million sq ft," Mehta said, adding the company is looking at targeting high net worth individuals and NRIs to sell the project.

The Delhi-NCR project is the fourth Trump Tower project in India after Pune, Mumbai, and Kolkata. In Pune, the global brand has licensed the Trump name to Panchshil Realty, in Mumbai to Lodha Group and in Kolkata, the Trump Organisation has partnered with Unimark Group to build a 400,000 sq ft residential project with the signature Trump Tower on the city’s EM Bypass stretch.

Join the Largest Community of Whatsapp Group of Real Estate Buyers in India on Real Estate Forum India for more information and news related to builders.


Friday, 1 June 2018

HUDA blacklist architects for forging photographs for completion certificate

GURUGRAM: The Haryana Urban Development Authority (HUDA) has blacklisted three architects for forging and submitting wrong information while applying for completion certificate (CC). The move was aimed at checking corruption in granting CC by Huda, which has emerged as one of the major source of corruption in the department.

Fraud Real Estate Companies - Cheated Buyers


The action was purportedly taken by the Estate officer while checking the files submitted to him by survey branch for approval. It was found that the architects had submitted morphed photographs of the sites showing them complete in all respect while a special team so constituted by the estate office found the same to the contrary on spot inspection. “Inquiry has been marked into the matter and will call for explanation of the concerned officials of the survey branch and necessary departmental action along with criminal proceedings shall be initiated post an enquiry,” said estate officer-II of Huda Vivek Kalia.

People having plots in HUDA sectors have to take CC from authority after completing construction. Getting CC is mandatory to get services like water, sewerage and power connection. In January 2017 Huda made it mandatory for all kinds of plots—residential, commercial and institutional to complete construction of minimum of 50% of ground coverage and gets CC. Failing to get CC in stipulated time Huda will automatically start charging the penalty as extension fee.

In most of the cases people submit forged photograph to get CC by greasing the palms of Huda officials. With the jurisdiction over sectors 23-80 were most of the construction activities are in progress, estate office-II of Huda Gurgaon has emerged as powerhouse amongst all the estates offices of authority in Haryana and thus a natural ground for touts and middle men. On increasing irregularities in granting CC, Kalia said initiatives are being taken to re-structure the entire processes of HUDA and probable solutions have already been proposed by his office to the headquarters and shall be introduced shortly. “Reliance on information technology and absolute or limited manual interface can cut down on wrongdoing which often we hear on a daily basis.

Besides, the onus is also on the citizenry to report such matters to senior officials of HUDA or on other such online grievances portal so made available to them in case of any issue,” said Kalia urging people to approach senior officials in case they face problem. He further states that a special whatsapp number monitored by the Vigilance branch of HUDA shall be introduced this week wherein applicants/individuals can lodge formal complaints of any official or non-official persons while dealing with Estate Office of HUDA.

Join the Largest Community of Whatsapp Group of Real Estate Buyers in India on Best Real Estate Review Website for more information and news related to builders.

Wednesday, 30 May 2018

Residents to protest delay in Sushant Lok 1 takeover by Gurugram civic body

Several residents have also alleged that common areas in the colony such as parks and community centers are being sold off quietly at a time when the government authorities and the developer are passing the buck on each other for the delay.



GURUGRAM : Agitated over the recurring delays in takeover of their colony by MCG, Sushant Lok-1 residents have decided to hit the streets again from March 4, alleging that differences among the civic body, department of town and country planning (DTCP) and developer Ansal API on the takeover cost is holding up the entire process of handover.

“The city authorities are ignoring our colony and giving a step-motherly treatment to it, citing legal hassles. Despite orders by the chief minister, the MCG is not taking any initiative to take over the colony from the developer. The CM had earlier said if the developer didn’t take into cognizance the expenses, the MCG would take over the colony and settle the issue on its own,” said Neelu Sharma, a resident, adding that their repeated pleas to various agencies during the last two years have fallen on the deaf ears.

Several residents have also alleged that common areas in the colony such as parks and community centres are being sold off quietly at a time when the government authorities and the developer are passing the buck on each other for the delay.

“The developer has already sold off over 50% of parks originally planned as per its 1986 sale layout. The developer’s sales office in the A block was a prime example, which was demolished in 2009 after protests from the residents. However, they somehow manage to get their plans implemented illegally,” said Shashi Sharma, a resident.

Sushant Lok-1 residents had earlier filed a complaint with the Gurugram police and the forest department against an alleged attempt by the developer to cut trees in a community park. “Residents want the developer to hand over the colony to the government, and are fighting them in court and tribunals. When will the government wake up from its slumber? Will there be an end to the encroachment attempt on the open areas of the colony? The remaining open areas are way below 45% already,” said AN Gupta, another resident. The process to take over Sushant Lok-1 had started in the summer of 2017.

Now, after the completion of the detailed project report and discussions at the ground level, the process has hit hurdles, with the developer refusing to pay the deficiency cost as prescribed in the MCG’s report. Ansal API Ltd denied the allegations raised by residents. “Ansal API is not selling off any community centres and parks. They have been under control of the resident welfare association (RWA) for last five years. We don’t know if they are selling common areas,” said a spokesperson for the developer.

Join the Largest Community of Whatsapp Group of Real Estate Buyers in India on Best Real Estate Review Website for more information and news related to builders.

Tuesday, 29 May 2018

Celina housing society takes Welworth Associates to HC over 'illegal construction'

PUNE: Residents of the Celina Cooperative Housing Society in Baner have moved the High Court against the builder raising objections to a recent construction started on the society premises by the latter. They have claimed that while the builder has delayed the conveyance deed, he is using the remaining land from the society premises, which he has no right on, to start a new construction. For their part, the Pune Municipal Corporation (PMC) has cited the district deputy registrar’s (DDR’s) order on the matter to claim that the permission for the new construction has been given legally.

Consumer Court Cases on Real Estate - Cheated Buyers


The residents of the society moved into their flats in 2006 and 2007 after the building completion certificate was issued. Following this, the final completion certificate for the society was issued in 2008. According to the petition filed with the high court, at this point the three main buildings of the society were completed while a fourth small structure was to be constructed and the cooperative society was also formed by the residents to manage its activities. But around this time the builder started delaying the process for deemed conveyance and the DDR issued an order in favour of the builder. Meanwhile, the builder also received the sanction for the construction on the vacant plot in the society. Following this, the members of the society immediately sent a legal notice to the PMC calling upon the civic body to cancel the construction permission. Based on this the residents of the society have also filed a writ petition against the DDR’s order and challenged the builder in the high court.

Speaking about this Niranjan Ghate, chairman of Celina Society, said, “The problem is that despite our having shifted to the society premises 13 years ago, the builder was not ready to do the conveyance deed. The deed would mean that the entire piece of land, on which the society is built, has been transferred to the society. But while we were protesting against the delay, based on the fact that the land was transferred to us when we formed the society, the builder started constructing a new building on the premises. While he had shown this as a small structure earlier, he managed to obtain the permission from the PMC for extra construction. We are also wondering how the PMC authorities gave them permission despite the matter being sub-judice. He had used all the available FSI in 2008. But he has started fresh construction now. We are demanding that till the time the matter is resolved the fresh construction should be put on hold.”

When quizzed about this, Mahesh Salunkhe, head of sales and marketing at Welworth Associates, the builder firm that constructed Celina said, “The residents are raising objections because they want the open space. But we never promised to give it to them and the plan for construction of the building has always been there. Even at the time of signing agreements the residents were aware of it. So they cannot question it now. We have put forth all the legal documents and data before the DDR and are going to present the same in the high court too.”

Join the Largest Community of Whatsapp Group of Real Estate Buyers in India on Best Real Estate Review Website for more information and news related to builders.

Sunday, 27 May 2018

Haryana govt to auction 100 acres from Global City land pool

GURUGRAM: The Haryana State Industrial and Infrastructure Development Corporation (HSIIDC) has decided to auction 100 acres from the land pool allocated for the Global City project. The auction will be done in parts and, in the first round, the corporation will put 20 acres adjoining the Dwarka Expressway on the block.



According to HSIIDC officials, latest estimates for the Global City project have thrown up a requirement of a little over a 1,000 acres. Consequently, a chunk of land measuring around 100 acres is available for other use. “We have decided to go with just 20 acres in the first round of auction to test the market and will then plan the subsequent auctions accordingly. The land is on either side of the Dwarka Expressway,” said Manoj Pal Singh, additional general manager, HSIIDC and head of the Global City project at HSIIDC.

Registrations for the first round have been opened and the last date to do so is December 13, 2017. The procedure and details for the registration are available on the HSIIDC portal. Intially, 1,383 acres were acquired for the project which has hit multiple hurdles. The Global City project is yet to be launched. The Manohar Lal Khattar government is keen on launching it at the earliest.

Singh said the land comes under mixed use development and is also applicable for benefits under the transit oriented development (TOD) policy. Since it is right next to the expressway, which is being developed as a national highway, HSIIDC hopes the auction will fetch it a good price. Talking about the expected price Singh said, “As of now, we don’t have any idea because different reports are projecting different prices. It is because of this reason that we have kept the reserve price open for the auction.”

However, according to sources at the corporation, the land should at least be worth around Rs 100 crore going by the prevailing rate of Rs 5 crore per acre. If it is anything less than that, the corporation would not make any substantial margins. The auction will also bring some relief for the corporation, which has been facing financial problems lately.

TOI had earlier reported that the HSIIDC has a huge debt of Rs 9,775 crore on account of increased land compensation costs to allottees across major industrial projects.This amount is the sum of all loans taken by the corporation till May 2017 for 18 different industrial projects.

You can keep track of your real estate developer by Whatsapp Group of Real Estate Buyers on Best Real Estate Review Website on facebook.

Friday, 25 May 2018

High - Rises in Gift City run into trouble

It’s third time unlucky for Gujarat International Finance Tec-City (GIFT), billed as India’s first global financial services and IT hub that’s coming up near Ahmedabad airport. 

The smart city project may have to scale down the height of several planned multi-storied buildings after a study that that it had specifically sought – the third such survey since 2008 – recommended that curbs on high-rises in the vicinity of the airport should be maintained without exception in the interests of aviation safety. 

Real Estate Project Review - Cheated Buyers


A committee of the aviation ministry approved the findings of a six month study by the International Civil Aviation Organization, which recommended heights ranging from 74 metres and 191 metres for 52 high-rise buildings in GIFT City, against requests from 68 metres to 474 metres. 

The financial and IT hub, being developed by state-owned Gujarat Urban Development Company Ltd. and Infrastructure Leasing & Financial Services Ltd, is located 12 km from Ahmedabad’s international airport. Prime Minister Narendra Modi said in January he envisioned GIFT as a centre that would set the prices of some of largest traded instruments in the world, including commodities, currencies and equities. 

The appellate committee on height clearance, under the Ministry of Civil Aviation, met on September 21 and approved the height limit recommendations for GIFT City, according to the minutes published on the website of the Airports Authority of India. Height restrictions on buildings and structures around airports are meant to aid navigation and keep flight paths clear during landings and take-offs 

Arun Kumar, a joint secretary in the ministry and chairman of the appellate committee, declined to comment on the matter. ET spoke to multiple officials in the ministry and AAI, who said the ICAO report was an endorsement of a study conducted by AAI. “There are prescribed permissible limits – it is about aircraft safety. No organisation can relax height by over 250 metres,” an aviation expert said. 

According to the minutes and annexures, the appellate committee approved height requests as sought by GIFT for 26 of the 52 structures, including one building that’s 191metres high.  However, height exemption requests for other structures were denied. In block B10, for which GIFT sought approval for a height of 474 metres, the permissible limit of 177 metres was granted. In block B13, GIFT sought a height of 305 metres and the permissible elevation of 183 metres was granted. The aeronautical study, the second by ICAO, was approved in July 2016 by the appellate committee following a request by GIFT City. 

According to the minutes of a meeting issued by the appellate committee at that time, GIFT was a project of “public importance.” “As GIFT wasn’t satisfied with AAIprescribed limits and insisted on ICAO study, the appellate committee agreed to their request,” a ministry official said.

You can keep track of your real estate developer by Whatsapp Group of Real Estate Buyers on Best Real Estate Review Website on facebook.

Thursday, 24 May 2018

MahaRERA comes to the aid of 30 more flat buyers of Tanvi Eminence project in Mira Road

MahaRERA comes to the aid of 30 more flat buyers of Tanvi Eminence project in Mira Road

Real Estate Project Review - Cheated Buyers


The Maharashtra Real Estate Regulatory Authority (MahaRERA) has come to the aid of 30 more flat buyers of the stalled Tanvi Eminence project in Mira Road and directed the developer to hand over possession of their apartments on or before December 31, 2019.

The order comes nearly a month after the court ordered a similar settlement for a welfare association representing 190 other flat buyers who had bought apartments in Tanvi Eminence Phase I and II. The project has been stalled since 2013 following differences between the four promoters of the project. MahaRERA chairperson Gautam Chatterjee had steered the project towards completion by holding long deliberations with the developer and the welfare association members, and given a landmark order last month based on consent terms signed between the two.

In his order, Chatterjee has directed the developers to hand over possession of the flats, including Occupancy Certificate, before December 31, 2019, with a grace period of three months for mitigating factors. The builder will be liable to pay interest on the money invested by the home buyers for any further delay.

As per the order, home buyers will receive the flats for the same price agreed in the allotment letter or registered sale agreements issued by the developer, barring any additional charges newly levied by the local bodies or government from time to time. While some home buyers had demanded compensation for their investments lying with the developer since 2012-13, it was not granted.

“We are satisfied with the consent terms. The developer has said that there will be no reduction in amenities promised to us and we will be charged Rs 4 lakh for car parking as promised earlier. The developer says construction has already started,” said Nilesh Thakkar, one of the 30 complainants who invested in the project in 2012.

You can keep track of your real estate developer by Whatsapp Group of Real Estate Buyers on Best Real Estate Review Website on facebook.


Wednesday, 23 May 2018

Today Homes' buyers protest; UP police assure action against builder

Noida, Hundreds of home buyers today staged a protest against realty firm Today Homes over non-completion of its residential project in sector 135 here, following which the UP police assured them of convening a meeting with the builder.

Frustrated Real Estate Buyers - Cheated Buyers


The home buyers first gathered at the site of the project, Ridge Residency, and advanced towards the local police station seeking intervention as the builder failed to deliver flats despite a long delay and many assurances in the past.

With home buyers insisting on the presence of top management of the company, including promoter GK Gambhir, the Uttar Pradesh police assured them that the builder would be served notice to be present at the police station for a meeting with buyers on April 28. SHO V S Pundir tried to contact officials of Today Homes Noida Private Ltd but could not succeed. "We will send a notice to the builder today itself to be present at the police station for a meeting with buyers on April 28. If he does not attend the meeting we will take action," Pundir said.

While seeking action against the builder, the home buyers also sought progress on around 40 FIRs filed by them. Comments from the company could not be obtained as phone calls to senior management and e-mail query remained unanswered. The Today Homes Ridge Residency is a 13-acre project, comprising 18 towers with over 1,800 flats. It was launched in 2009-10 and its completion was scheduled for 2013-14.

"There has been a significant delay in the completion of the project. The builder has been giving us deadline after deadline for the completion of the project without honouring it. Even the police is not taking action despite many FIRs being lodged," said Rajesh Sharma, a home buyer.

Thousands of home buyers of many builders, including Jaypee group, Unitech and Amrapali, in Delhi-NCR region, are waiting for deliveries of flats, forcing them to resort to protest and even file court cases seeking possession, refund of money with interest and action against the errant builders.

Join the Largest Community of Whatsapp Group of Real Estate Buyers in India on Best Real Estate Review Website for more information and news related to builders.

Tuesday, 22 May 2018

Ardee City residents in Gurugram say no to new power meters

GURUGRAM: Hundreds of angry residents of Adree City in Sector 52, on Saturday, protested against the recent decision of the builder to replace their postpaid power meters and install prepaid ones without their consent — a move, they suspect, will allow the latter to charge fees exceeding the Haryana Electricity Regulatory Commission’s (HERC) mandated tariff rate.

Real Estate Project Review - Cheated Buyers


Residents said they noticed this “surreptitious activity” by Adree Infrastructure Pvt Ltd last week, following which they raised a hue and cry, which culminated into the protest on Saturday. Residents started gathering in front of the main office of the Ardee management near Gate No 1 of the society from 11am, and the number soon increased to hundreds. “The builder is changing the meters without our consent,” said Praveen Yadav, president of Ardee City RWA.

Yadav said the builder was replacing the old meters with those enabling them to make payments through prepaid mode without their consent. “The builder wants to levy illegal charges through a prepaid meter. As per HERC guidelines, it is clearly written that such meters should be changed only if the consumer opts for it,” he said.

Prepaid meters work in the same way as prepaid SIM cards. Consumers have to pay a specific amount in advance, which reflects in their meters and exhausts progressively with the number of units consumed. Users get periodic notifications about the units consumed and remaining units so that they can recharge before power is cut.

Residents said HERC officials visiting the society in December last year had advised the residents to file a petition against such a ‘capitation charge’ as it wasn’t complying with HERC guidelines. “Even HERC agreed it’s illegal. Previously, they used to mint extra charges in the name of transmission and distribution losses, but eventually DHBVN sent a stinging letter saying such charges are already incorporated in the bills. We have a single point connection, which means DHBVN doesn’t give electricity directly to us, but to the builder, who further distributes it to residents,” said Chaitali Mandhotra, another resident.

In the letter to the builder, which is in possession of TOI, the discom in May earlier this year wrote: “The distribution licensee shall not charge a tariff in excess of the tariff determined by the Commission.” The letter further warned that if any distribution licensee recovers a price or charge at a rate exceeding the tariff determined under the regulations, it shall be liable to penalties. “Since the residents are not paying illegal charges added to the electricity bill, the builder has resorted to cheap tactics by disconnecting power. When asked to fix the problem, they are coercing residents to pay the charges,” said Ardee RWA general secretary Nehal Mandhotra.

Anil Hasija, vice-president of Ardee Infrastructure, did not take calls despite repeated attempts. General manager Chandan Lakhanpal listened to the queries we raised before hanging up the phone and not responding to further calls.

Join the Largest Community of Whatsapp Group of Real Estate Buyers in India on Best Real Estate Review Website for more information and news related to builders.


Monday, 21 May 2018

Sebi to auction 18 properties of Kolkata's MPS Greenery Developers next month

Sebi to auction 18 properties of Kolkata's MPS Greenery Developers next month

Best Real Estate Review Website - Cheated Buyers


NEW DELHI: To recover investors' money, markets regulator Sebi has lined up as many as 18 properties of MPS Greenery Developers for an online auction next month at a total reserve price of over Rs 67 crore.

This is in addition to the 18 properties auctioned in February and 14 assets in June last year. The Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) has initiated the process for sale of assets of the company, as per an order by the Calcutta High Court.

Justice Sailendra Prasad Talukdar has been appointed as the one-man committee for liquidating the assets of MPS Group of companies and repaying the investors. Subsequently, the committee directed Sebi to proceed with auction of select properties of MPS Group.

SBI Capital Markets has been engaged by Sebi to assist in sale of the properties through e-auction platform on "as is where is and whatever there is" basis. The West Bengal-based firm gathered Rs 1,520 crore from investors through illegal collective investment schemes.

In a notice issued today, the regulator will auction 18 properties on June 19 at a reserve price of over Rs 67 crore. The property listed for sale include land parcels, buildings, residential flats and commercial space in Kolkata.

Besides, intending bidders can inspect these properties on June 5. In December 2012, the markets regulator had directed MPS Greenery Developers to close its illicit collective investment schemes and refund investors within one month, failing which proceedings would be initiated against the entity and its senior officials.

Join the Largest Community of Whatsapp Group of Real Estate Buyers in India on Best Real Estate Review Website.

Wednesday, 16 May 2018

No eco clearance for Nitesh's apartment project on 'lake land'

The State Environment Impact Assessment Authority (SEIAA) has rejected the application of Nitesh Urban Development Pvt Ltd for environmental clearance to its residential apartment project at Bhoganahalli village in Bengaluru South taluk.

Real Estate Project Review - Cheated Buyers


The developer wants to construct apartments in two parcels of land on a total plot area of 44,880.93 square metres. The SEIAA’s rejection came on October 12. “We refused the environmental clearance because the land where the project has been proposed is lake land. Bengaluru has been witnessing flash floods lately. If such projects are cleared, the chances of flooding will only rise,” Ramachandra, member secretary, SEIAA, told DH.

According to the Ministry of Environment, Forests and Climate Change, environmental clearance is mandatory for any large housing and infrastructure project. The developer wants to construct apartments with lower and upper basements, a ground floor and 13 floors and a stair headroom with 297 units each in two parcels of land in survey numbers 22, 23/1, 23/2, 24, 25/2, 26/1f, 26/2, 27, 28, 29/1, 29/2, 29/3 and 29/4 at Bhoganahalli.

At the meeting, SEIAA members also noted that the proposed site is in a low-lying area that would be prone to inundation. Therefore, the construction of such a large residential complex will be unsuitable, they stressed. The minutes of the meeting, a copy of which has been seen by DH, mention that the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC), too, had taken note of the ambiguity regarding the Bhoganahalli waterbody in Survey No 29 at its meeting on February 27, 2017.

The SEIAA noted that section 14 (2) of the Karnataka Lake Conservation and Development Authority (KLCDA) Act, 2014, bans construction on any lakebed. Both the SEIAA and the SEAC feared the construction would affect the buffer area as the company’s proposal does not show any other approach road to the project site. The SEIAA also stated that the land belongs to the gram panchayat and as per the Supreme Court orders of January 28, 2011, in civil appeal number 1132/2011, the land should be restored to the panchayat for the common use of villagers (locals). 

On February 23 this year, the SEIAA had refused to give environmental clearance to 28 developers/companies that had been seeking it since 2014. Among the companies were Mantri Techzone Private Limited and Coremind Software and Services Private Limited.

Join the Largest Community of Whatsapp Group of Real Estate Buyers in India on Best Real Estate Review Website.

Tuesday, 15 May 2018

Home Buyers of Bhagtani project get new Offer

Mira Road project investors say builder ready to shift them to non-Bhagtani projects. Several home buyers who have their money stuck in the stillborn Bhagtani Riyo project in Mira Road have received calls from the developer JVPD Properties offering to transfer their ownership to another non-Bhagtani project.

Real Estate Project Review - Cheated Buyers


Speaking to Mumbai Mirror, Majid Sheliya, a Bhagtani Riyo investor and an intervenor in the court case presently being heard by the Bombay High Court, said “I got a call on Tuesday from Kinjal in Bhagtani office who offered that they can give me a flat in Shubh Atika project by Ravi Developers in Mira Road which is registered with MahaRERA. Kinjal said they will pay the amount I have invested with 15 per cent interest directly to that builder without I having to invest anything.”

Sheliya, who owns an optical store and had invested Rs 7.59 lakh in Bhagtani Riyo in April 2013, said “Kinjal said I will get possession of the flat in Shubh Atika by January 2020. When I checked I found that though this project is registered with MahaRERA, its possession date is December 31 2022, which is five years from now. I refused the offer and asked for my refund. I told them I don’t trust them any longer and that only if they transfer me to a ready possession project will I agree.”

Sheliya, who lives in a rented flat while waiting for his dream home for last four years, also pointed out that when he booked the flat in Bhagtani Riyo, he got a rate of Rs 4,000 per sq feet whereas he would have to shell more money for a flat in Shubh Atika. “The ongoing rate in Shubh Atika is Rs 6200 per sq feet. So, a 700 sq ft flat will cost me Rs 43 to Rs 44 lakh,” he said.

Another Bhagtani Riyo investor Deepak Brid also received a phone call from Bhagtani developer’s office this week. “I and my brother in law Keenan had invested Rs 8.37 lakh including stamp duty and registration in a 1 and 2 BHK flats in 2013. The Bhagtani representative said on telephone that they will pay my investment with 15 per cent interest directly to the developer of Shubh Atika and I could transfer my flat there. Or they suggested that I could shift to a project with Occupancy Certificate in Boisar but did not name the project. But, I refused the offer.”

Brid, who works with a private bank and lives in a rented flat in Borivali, said after two years of repeated promises that the Riyo Project will progress, he and his brother-in-law had demanded a refund of their money in December 2015 and yet to get it.

When contacted, Diipesh Bhagtani, director of JVPD Properties and Jaycee Homes, said “This is not a new development. We have been offering these transfers to our customers through some structured deals with other developers and brokers. But, we do not pay that developer directly. We will refund the customer their dues with interest, and they will have to then take it forward with the developer. Obviously, the rate of that flat will be at the present ongoing rate.”

“We have been trying to help people who want a refund. There are cash flow issues in the market. The market is down, and we have the customers. So if the home buyer is ready to take a transfer to another developer’s project, we have been facilitating that. Many people have taken such transfers,” Bhagtani claimed.

Join the Largest Community of Whatsapp Group of Real Estate Buyers in India on Best Real Estate Review Website.


Thursday, 10 May 2018

HC slams administrator's actions, orders South Mumbai society office unsealed

MUMBAI: In a relief to residents of Grand Paradi, a landmark highrise at Kemps Corner in South Mumbai, a day after an administrator sealed the housing society's office, the Bombay high court noting his unseemly haste in doing so, directed it to be immediately unsealed.

Consumer Court Cases on Real Estate - Cheated Buyers


Sachin Sheth and nine other members of the managing committee of the Grand Paradi cooperative housing society had moved HC on Friday. They had challenged an order of cooperative minister, Subhash Deshmukh, in appointing an administrator and his swift action in sealing the office. On December 6, the minister, as an appellate authority, directed that an administrator be appointed after a dispute over excessive transfer fees of Rs 34 lakh from members was escalated to him.

Justice Gautam Patel, before whom the committee counsel J P Sen sought urgent relief, observed, "The order passed only two days ago was sought to be implemented peremptorily. Yesterday (December 7) the administrator sealed the society's office.'' The state's lawyer informed the court that the "administrator will proceed at once to unseal that office, no later than by noon on Saturday.''

Justice Patel also directed the administrator not to take any further action till January 9. Justice Patel in a cutting observation said, "In the one day that he was enthroned, the administrator had sent letters to the society's banks.'' The HC directed him to now "immediately write to all banks requesting them not to act on his previous letter pending further communication.''

Y S Jahagirdar appearing for ordinary members of the society, who were the original complainants against the high-handedness of the managing committee, said that the minister's order to appoint the administrator was justified. The matter will now be listed before an appropriate bench for hearing on December 15. Mont Blanc Properties had built Grand Paradi's iconic three towers and 14 row houses four decades ago.

You can keep track of your real estate developer by Whatsapp Group of Real Estate Buyers on Best Real Estate Review Website on facebook.

Wednesday, 9 May 2018

Hyderabad: 109 buildings come-up in buffer area of Pedda Cheruvu lake

HYDERABAD: It has come to light that in Ramanthapur, which witnessed severe flooding during heavy rains last week, as many as 109 buildings, including 16 residential apartments and another 93 independent houses, have come up in the Full Tank Level (FTL) of Pedda Cheruvu in the past two decades. Interestingly, most of these structures were permitted by civic bodies such as the Greater Hyderabad Municipal Corporation (GHMC), erstwhile Uppal municipality, Hyderabad Metropolitan Development Authority (HMDA) and erstwhile Uppal gram panchayats.

Real Estate Project Review - Cheated Buyers


Now, both GHMC and HMDA are clueless on how to tackle the situation at Pedda Cheruvu, the main hurdle being removing all structures to protect the FTL and fence the area. Most of the lake buffer and FTL area is patta land and occupants can be removed only on payment of compensation to them. According to an estimate based on prevailing market rates, the state government would need `200 crore towards compensation.

According to officials, the irrigation and revenue departments confirmed that of the 32.5 acres, the lake is now left with only 22 acres. In the remaining area, colonies such as Ravindra Nagar, Laxmi Nagar and Saichitra Nagar have come up and of the structures there, over 100 are located on the full tank level.

A few days ago, Ravindra Nagar got inundated due to heavy rains. It took three da ys for the civic body and 14 pump sets to drain out water from the colonies. “Water remained stagnant till the sill level of the existing pipe drains across the national highway , which is also the FTL level. There is no sluice to the lake to release water to other areas,“ GHMC zonal commissioner (East Zone) BV Gangadhar Reddy told TOI.

HMDA commissioner T Chiranjeevulu, who is also chairman of the Lake Protection Committee, said, “Regarding lakes in GHMC limits, the HC ordered for acquiring land and buildings, especially patta land, to maintain FTL of lakes. But it is a costly affair.“

Join the Largest Community of Whatsapp Group of Real Estate Buyers in India on Best Real Estate Review Website for more information and news related to builders.

Wednesday, 2 May 2018

SC to examine plea challenging HC order against Noida's Mist Avenue

NEW DELHI: The Supreme Court has agreed to examine a plea challenging an order of the Allahadbad High Court by which it quashed criminal proceedings against Noida-based real estate builders. 

Real Estate Project Review - Cheated Buyers


A bench of justices Arun Mishra and U U Lalit issued notice on a plea filed by a buyer, named Ashish Gupta, who claimed that the High Court erred in quashing the proceedings in a criminal case against the builders, and that it was an utter violation of natural justice. 

Advocate J P Singh, appearing for Gupta, said that it is "serious abuse of authority" and the High Court cannot quash the proceedings in a criminal matter on the ground of existence of arbitration clause.  "Criminal prosecution cannot be quashed under the garb of arbitration Clause. The criminal proceedings are independent proceedings and they cannot be wiped out on the false pretext of arbitration clause," Singh said. 

He alleged that local police were hand-in-gloves with the power real estate builders and had refused to lodge a FIR following which the petitioner had to approach to court for lodging the case of cheating, forgery and criminal conspiracy. 

Singh said that the accused builder Satinder Singh Bhasin and others moved the Allahabad High Court, which ordered stay on arrest of the builders, without giving an opportunity to the petitioner (property buyer).  Gupta in his plea said that on December 13, 2017, the high court had quashed the charge-sheet, cognizance order and the entire criminal proceedings under various sections of IPC on the false pretext of arbitration clause. 

Gupta in his plea said that in 2012, managing director Satinder Singh Bhasin and Mohinder Singh Ahluwalia of M/s Mist Avenue Pvt Ltd published false, fake and misleading multiple advertisements in print and electronic media to induce the home buyers of the project at Noida. 

He deposited money for a retail shop booked on November 21, 2012, to earn livelihood and the delivery of possession was promised to be given of the same within two years.  "Even after lapse of more than six years the construction of the project is at initial stage. Now the construction has completely been stopped and project is lying in a dilapidated condition," the plea said. 

He claimed that till now he has paid Rs 32,43,840 through cheques to the Mist Avenue Builders but possession of the property has not been given.

Join the Largest Community of Whatsapp Group of Real Estate Buyers in India on Best Real Estate Review Website.

Tuesday, 1 May 2018

Refund investors at MCLR rates, MahaRERA tells two developers

Refund investors at MCLR rates, MahaRERA tells two developers

Whatsapp Group of Real Estate Buyers - Cheated Buyers


The Maharashtra Real Estate Regulatory Authority (MahaRERA) has directed two developers – Neptun Developers Ltd, and Jangid Constructions – to refund the respective complainants their invested sum for delay in giving possession of flats at two per cent higher than SBI’s highest prevailing Marginal Cost of Lending Rate (MCLR).

In the first case, home buyer Balu Bhawar had booked a flat in Neptune Swarajya housing project located in Ambivali near Titwala under a registered agreement for sale on December 14, 2012. Bhawar said in his complaint filed with the housing regulatory authority that even after five years, the developer failed to give possession of the flat. Moreover, after the developer deferred the date of completion of the project on MahaRERA website to December 31, 2018, he did not wish to continue invested in the project.

The complaint was heard by MahaRERA chairperson Gautam Chatterjee. The developer’s advocates explained that the reasons for the delay in completion project were beyond their control, and the complainant and the developer mutually agreed to a fresh possession date of March 31, 2018.

“The respondent (developer) is directed to hand over the possession of the flat to the complainant before the period ending March 2018, failing which the respondent shall be liable to pay interest to the complaint from April 2018 till the actual possession on the entire amount paid by the complainant to the respondent,” the order said adding that the developer will be liable to pay interest at the State Bank of India’s highest Marginal Cost of Lending Rate (MCLR) prevailing at the time plus two per cent as prescribed under Rule 18 of the MahaRERA rules.

Join the Largest Community of Whatsapp Group of Real Estate Buyers in India on Best Real Estate Review Website for more information and news related to builders.